Submit the moment
Find the key moment on YouTube, trim it to the shortest useful segment, choose the sport and question, then send it for approval.
More preparation · More Pride
Watch · Judge · Earn trust
Every call
builds your legacy.
CommunityReview turns useful participation into Pride—the reputation you earn by showing up, making fair calls, and helping keep the review board trustworthy.
Rank preview
Example Pride
1,240PTS
Current position
Playmaker
260 to
All-Star
Pride cannot be bought. It is a record of effort, judgment, and trust.
How it works
Three ways to make your mark
You do not need to be an expert on day one. Start with a call, build a fair track record, and take on more responsibility when you are ready.
Make the call
Watch the full segment, pick the decision that matches the evidence, and see where your verdict lands with the community.
Quick effort · Steady Pride
Protect the board
Report genuine problems. Qualified members can become moderators and review clips for relevance, safety, and fair context.
Highest responsibility · Highest Pride
Pride points
Effort has a score.
Pride gives real weight to useful actions. Small actions add up; work that takes more care earns more.
Quality beats quantity
No Pride is awarded for repeat votes, rejected or withdrawn videos, unconfirmed reports, or overturned moderation. Abuse can remove points and rank.
Vote on a play
Your first valid verdict on an approved video. Changing it does not pay twice.
+2
Confirmed report
Awarded only when a report helps moderators confirm a real issue.
+5
Approved video
For finding the moment, trimming the clip, and adding accurate context.
+25
Video reaches 25 votes
A quality bonus for submitting a play the community finds worth reviewing.
+10
Video reaches 100 votes
A second quality bonus for an especially useful contribution.
+25
Audited moderation
Awarded after a completed case passes the review window.
+15
Priority moderation
For a valid reported or safety-sensitive case that passes audit.
+20
Positions
From first whistle to GOAT
Your position is a visible record of contribution. Higher ranks show consistency; they never make one person’s vote count more than another’s.
-
1 0 pts
Newcomer
Learn the field
-
2 50 pts
Rookie
Build your record
-
3 150 pts
Prospect
Show consistency
-
4 400 pts
Starter
Moderator eligible
-
5 800 pts
Playmaker
Trusted contributor
-
6 1,500 pts
All-Star
Proven judgment
-
7 3,000 pts
Captain
Community leader
-
8 6,000 pts
MVP
Elite contributor
-
9 10,000 pts
Legend
Lasting impact
-
10 20,000 pts
GOAT
The highest standard
Become a moderator
Earn the booth.
Moderators are trusted members who keep reviews relevant, safe, and fairly framed. Starter rank unlocks eligibility—not automatic promotion.
Start building Pride
1
Build a trusted record
Reach Starter (400 Pride), keep an account for 30 days, cast 100 valid votes, submit 5 approved videos, and have no active strikes.
2
Pass the fairness check
Eligible members may be invited to review sample cases. Selection considers accuracy, consistency, and the current need for moderators.
3
Review with accountability
Moderator actions are logged and audited. Pride arrives after the review window, and repeated poor or biased decisions can remove access.
The rules
Compete on judgment. Win on trust.
These standards apply to every rank, including moderators and the GOAT.
Keep it sports-only
Submit a real sports incident and the shortest useful YouTube segment—never a compilation, reaction, or unrelated clip.
Give the whole moment
Do not crop time or context to steer the result. The call should stand on what viewers can actually see.
Vote on the evidence
Choose the call you believe is correct. Do not coordinate votes, use extra accounts, or chase points.
Protect the people
No harassment, private information, graphic content, or targeting individuals. Clips involving recognizable minors may be rejected.
Respect the source
We embed YouTube segments; we do not host video. Do not abuse copyright or submit content you know should not be shared.
Remember what this is
The result is community opinion—not an official ruling, appeal, or replacement for a referee.
Need the complete policy? Read the Community Guidelines.
Your next position starts here